Law Grad in Pink is a blog written by a law graduate in Adelaide for law graduates everywhere.

Showing posts with label unfair dismissal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unfair dismissal. Show all posts

Tuesday, 27 June 2017

Medical certificates – when can an employer question an employee’s evidence?


When an employee provides a medical certificate stating the employee is not fit to work, the employer must generally grant the employee personal leave (sick leave) for the relevant period. Section 96 of the Fair Work Act 2009 provides an employee with 10 days of paid personal/carer’s leave for each year of service, accumulating progressively. To take personal leave, the employee must be unfit for work because of a personal illness, or a personal injury effecting them (s.97). A certificate from a medical professional stating the employee is unfit for work must prima facie be taken as evidence, satisfying the requirement under s.97. However, where the employer has a real suspicion the medical certificate is fabricated or that the employee is fit to work, there are some situations in which the employer may be able to challenge the employee’s evidence. I will discuss three situations in this blog post:
  1. The employer suspects the medical certificate is fraudulent;
  2. The employer suspects the medical certificate has been altered by the employee; and
  3. The employer believes that despite a valid medical certificate being produced, the employee was fit to work in the period.
  1. Employer suspects medical certificate is fraudulent
In examining a medical certificate, an employer should look to see whether the medical certificate contains basic information such as the information listed in the AMA Guidelines for Medical Practitioners on Certificates Certifying Illness 2011 (revised 2016):
  1. Name and address of the doctor issuing the certificate;
  2. Name of the patient;
  3. Date on which the examination took place;
  4. Date on which the certificate was issued; and
  5. Date(s) on which the patient is or was unfit for attendance (5.1).
General practitioners are not bound to follow these guidelines and an absence of one of these items does not mean the medical certificate was not validly issued. While the AMA Guidelines state the certificate should be legible and written so that a non-medical person is able to read and understand it and be written on stationery designed specifically for this purpose (5.3), my experience as a legal practitioner is that this guideline is often not followed by doctors. While a medical practice will not provide any information about a patient or a patient’s condition (due to privacy obligations), they will ordinarily be willing to simply confirm whether or not a doctor works at the practice or whether or not a doctor issued the certificate. However, before making such an inquiry, the employer should have real reason to doubt the validity of the medical certificate.
The absence of a doctor’s name or doctor provider number could be sufficient reason to make inquiries. In Tokoda v Westpac Banking Corporation [2012] FWA 1262 Ms Tokoda presented her employer with a medical certificate that did not have the doctor’s provider number on it. The employer then made inquiries with the medical practice and was told that the doctor had not provided the certificate and that the employee had not been present at the medical practice since 2009. After an investigation the employee’s employment was terminated, as Westpac had lost the trust in the employee necessary for her continued employment in the banking industry. The FWC dismissed the unfair dismissal application, taking into account the fact the employee worked in a bank, a position requiring the highest standards of honesty and integrity. The employee was not just dishonest in falsifying the certificate but continued to be dishonest afterwards during the investigation. Note this case is specific to the facts and even where a medical certificate is found to be fraudulent, it should not be seen as a “slam dunk” reason for summary dismissal.
  1. Employer suspects medical certificate has been altered by the employee
In Hammond v Australian Red Cross Blood Services – Sydney [2011] FWA 1346, a nurse Ms Hammond brought an unfair dismissal claim against the Australian Red Cross after her employment was terminated following her production of an altered medical certificate.
Ms Hammond sustained a back injury at work and was on reduced duties and restricted hours in the period before producing the altered certificate. She obtained a WorkCover Medical Certificate on 6 September 2010 which cited only one restriction “avoid mobile units”. The medical certificate did not cite the list of restrictions that had been on previous medical certificates. Ms Hammond contacted the medical centre, spoke to the receptionist and asked whether the doctor had wanted all the restrictions included. The receptionist advised her she could put further restrictions on the certificate. Ms Hammond made those changes to the certificate believing the doctor had given her permission to do so. The Australian Red Cross obtained a copy of the medical certificate directly from the medical practice and called Ms Hammond into a meeting without a support person or union official to explain the discrepancies. She explained how she had altered the certificate. The Australian Red Cross summarily dismissed her (albeit with notice).
The FWC found Ms Hammond had been unfairly dismissed as her conduct did not constitute a wilful or deliberate attempt to commit an act striking at the heart of the employment relationship. The reasons the employer provided for dismissal being fraud and corruption and breach of a code of conduct were not sound, defensible or well founded. Ms Hammond was reinstated.
Deputy President Sams found the conduct warranted a warning only. Employers should take note of the following paragraph:
That said, it troubles me to say that I find the conduct of the respondent towards the applicant, from July to September 2010, to be appalling and unacceptable. The respondent’s actions ill behove the standards of behaviour I would expect from any employer; let alone one of the size, functionality and reputation of the Red Cross Blood Service. In my view, the respondent embarked on a deliberate and reprehensible campaign to threaten the applicant’s ongoing employment, based primarily on the grounds of her unfitness to fulfil her pre-injury duties. When it found what it thought to be the perfect grounds for the applicant’s dismissal - her alteration of the 6 September 2010 medical certificate - it pounced on her with speed and gusto, denied her procedural fairness and accused her, without mincing words, of the most serious of conduct, being corruption and fraud. I believe the applicant’s consequent dismissal to be manifestly unjust. On any objective analysis, the applicant’s alteration of a medical certificate was nowhere near what any reasonable person might consider to be corrupt, fraudulent or illegal conduct. This is so, not only because of the nature of the conduct itself, but because of the circumstances surrounding the conduct. That is not to say that the applicant’s alteration of the certificate can be condoned or that she is entirely blameless for what happened. Indeed, she readily admits that she did the wrong thing. But given the following circumstances, the applicant’s conduct warranted no more than a warning, and most certainly not summary dismissal for fraud and corruption.
Employers should be very wary when alleging a medical certificate has been altered. Even where there is clear evidence showing the employee has altered the certificate, it will likely only warrant a warning unless it is done in such a way that is so significant such that it destroys the trust required in the employment relationship.
  1. Employer believes that despite a valid medical certificate, the employee was fit to work in the period
In Anderson v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2008] FMCA 152, the Federal Magistrate’s Court upheld an employer’s decision to dismiss an employee after the employee had attended a football game while on sick leave.
Mr Anderson provided his employer Crown Melbourne with a medical certificate from a registered medical practitioner covering 1 September 2007. On 1 September 2007 Mr Anderson had attended the Essendon against West Coast game in Perth. He had obtained the medical certificate from Dr Salter on 27 August 2007 which covered the period of 1 September 2007. He had discussed going to the game with a number of colleagues including his supervisor and had spoken of his intention to obtain a medical certificate for this period (at this time he had already obtained the medical certificate covering 1 September 2007). On 29 August 2007 his supervisor Mr Branson met with him and said that misuse of sick leave will be treated very seriously. Mr Anderson said he would have a medical certificate. Mr Branson responded that he did not see that attending a football match was a legitimate use of sick leave. On 2 September 2007 when Mr Anderson attended work he was called into a meeting where he asserted it was not up to the Crown to question his medical certificate.
Federal Magistrate Burchardt preferred the evidence of Mr Anderson to Dr Salter and found that Mr Anderson had told Dr Salter he wanted to see the game at Subiaco on 1 September 2007 and made it plain this was very important to him. Dr Salter without it even being requested gave him a sick leave certificate for one day to enable him to do so and gave evidence that he formed the view Mr Anderson would be distressed as a football fanatic if he was unable to attend and may find it difficult concentrating at work. Dr Salter conceded that issuing a certificate as he did on 27 August 2007 dated 1 September 2007 was itself inappropriate and improper. Dr Salter had previously had two incidents of difficulties with accuracy in issuing medical certificates. On the two occasions the Medical Practitioners Board of Victoria found Dr Salter was a man of a particularly compassionate nature and had allowed that compassion to overbear his professional judgment.
The Federal Magistrate then considered whether Mr Burchardt had indeed been ill on 1 September 2007. He decided that the evidence showed Mr Anderson was at all time in excellent physical health, was not suffering from depression or other diagnosable medical condition and that despite the medical certificate Mr Anderson was not ill on 1 September 2007 and that the subsequent termination of his employment was not unfair.
While the case was decided under the old Workplace Relations Act 1996 on very unique facts, employees and employers should note the following points:
  1. A medical certificate from a qualified medical practitioner within the practitioner's area of expertise is prima facie to be accepted ([80]).
  2. It would only be in the most unusual and exceptional circumstances that an employer and/or by inference a Court would not accept the validity of such a certificate ([81]).
  3. A court or an employer is not necessarily bound to treat a medical certificate as binding on them where an unusual or exceptional circumstance exists ([79]).
It is a high risk approach to commence investigations merely because the employee was seen “out and about” when they were on sick leave, as the employer will generally not be aware of the exact reason why the employee is unfit for work on the day. If an employee is unfit to work because of a mental illness, it may be beneficial to their treatment to attend social gatherings with family members. A doctor ordinarily will not specify on a medical certificate the condition the employee is suffering from.
Risks
There are risks associated with taking action such as issuing a warning or dismissing an employee including unfair dismissal and adverse action claims. To reduce the risk of a successful adverse action claims, employers should be careful to focus on the medical certificate as evidence and not the employee’s time taken off work. If discrepancies are found, the emphasis should be on the dishonesty and breach of trust arising from the fraudulent/altered medical certificate.
Personal leave is a workplace right under s. 341 of the Fair Work Act and the failure to provide personal leave to which an employee is entitled may constitute adverse action under s. 432(1). However, an employee is only entitled to take personal leave where the employee is not fit for work because of a personal illness or personal injury affecting the employee. An employer must ensure they are able to establish any action taken against an employee was not taken because an employee was exercising their right to personal leave. The onus will be on the employer, as it will be presumed the action was taken because the employee was exercising their right to personal leave unless the employer proves otherwise (s. 361).
Employers should act cautiously when approaching medical certificates and only begin investigations when there is a valid reason to question the medical certificate. A valid reasons to make further inquiries might include where the date on the medical certificate has been obviously erased and altered or where the medical certificate has been issued by a doctor who retired years ago.
Summary
Remember the basics. Medical certificates should prima facie be taken at face value. Before making further inquiries the employer should have a real reason to do so. An employer should only challenge the evidence in a medical certificate issued by a medical professional in “unusual or exceptional circumstances” (Anderson v Crown Melbourne).  

Thursday, 23 February 2017

Probation periods and minimum employment periods – a guide for employees

It is common for an employer to place a new employee on a probation period ranging from a few weeks to a few months. The intention of a probation period is for the employer to assess the employee’s performance and ensure their suitability of the role. In this blog post I detail the legal position of employees on probation and explain how the probation period and unfair dismissal regime interact. Information in this blog post is only relevant to national system employees (see sections 13 and 14 of the Fair Work Act 2009).

Characteristics of probation periods
The length of a probation period can be found in the employment contract and/or letter of engagement. Employees on probation are entitled to accrue and access entitlements provided under the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) including annual leave and sick leave. Probation is not a separate period of employment and any entitlements accrued will carry over after probation has ended.
At the end of a probation period you should receive a letter confirming that your probation period has ended and that your employment will continue. Ideally you will also have a meeting with your employer at this time to receive feedback.

How long can a probation period be?
The length of a probation period is at the discretion of the employer. However, note the information below about the minimum employment period and protection from unfair dismissal. A probation period is a separate concept to a minimum employment period. A probation period is selected by the employer and reflected in the employment contract or letter of engagement, whereas the minimum employment period is a statutory period set under s.383 of the FW Act. While it is logical for an employer to select a probation period the same as a minimum employment period (generally 6 months), this will not be the case in every situation.
An employer can only extend a probation period if the employment contract allows for an extension or if the employee agrees to the extension. In contrast an employer cannot extend the statutory minimum employment period (discussed below).

What if I do not pass a probation period?
An employer does not have to wait until the completion of a probation period to terminate an employee. Employees who do not pass a probation period are still entitled to receive the appropriate notice for the cessation of their employment and be paid out unused annual leave and other accrued entitlements. The minimum notice requirement where an employee has 1 year or less continuous service is 1 week of notice.
While an employee who fails to pass a probation period may not be protected from unfair dismissal, the employee may be able to take action against their employer under general protections laws, anti-discrimination laws, or breach of employment contract. Employees should also familiarise themselves with any additional rights provided in an applicable award or enterprise agreement.

Can I make an unfair dismissal claim?
The unfair dismissal regime in the FW Act is available to employees who earn less than the high income threshold (currently $138,900) and who have completed the minimum employment period (s.382). The minimum employment period is 6 months or 1 year for small business employers (s.383). The probation period and the minimum employment period may overlap, as employers often choose a six month probation period, enabling the employer to terminate the employee’s employment prior to the end of the probation period, meaning the employee is not protected from unfair dismissal. However, it is possible for a probation period to be longer than the minimum employment period. For example where a probation period for an employee working for a large company is 12 months and an employee’s employment is terminated at 11 months, the employee will be protected by the unfair dismissal regime as the six month minimum employment period will be satisfied.  

Remember that an unfair dismissal application must be made within 21 days of the date of dismissal so if you believe you have a claim you should seek legal advice as soon as possible after the date of dismissal (s 366 Fair Work Act 2009).  

Why the confusion?
The difference between a probation period and a minimum employment period appears straight forward. Confusion among practitioners and those working in human resources appears to have arisen from hanging on to old concepts that applied under the old Workplace Relations Act 1996 (WR Act).
Section 643 of the WR Act provided that an employee wishing to make an application relating to their termination of employment must among other criteria have served the qualifying period of employment. The definition of qualifying period of employment differs from the definition of the minimum employment period under the FW Act. Section 643(7) of the WR Act provided:

(7)  For the purposes of subsection (6), the qualifying period of employment is:
(a)  6 months; or
(b)  a shorter period, or no period, determined by written agreement between the employee and employer before the commencement of the employment; or
(c)  a longer period determined by written agreement between the employee and employer before the commencement of the employment, being a reasonable period having regard to the nature and circumstances of the employment.

As you can see from the wording of the section, the WR Act allowed the employee and employer to agree to a shorter or longer qualifying period of employment. It was therefore practical for employers under the old WR Act to make the qualifying period of employment the same as the probation period and the qualifying period of employment was often referred to as the probation period. This flexibility to agree on a shorter or longer qualifying period no longer exists. The FW Act provides a statutory minimum employment period of 6 months (1 year for small business employees) and this is a separate concept to a probation period the employer may include in a contract of employment.


Thursday, 8 December 2016

Work Christmas parties – lessons from the 2015 Christmas season


Christmas season is here again meaning there will be a string of work Christmas parties and functions for employees to attend. In December last year I wrote about Keenan v Leighton BoralAmey NSW Pty Ltd[2015] FWC 3156, a complicated unfair dismissal case resulting from an employee’s inappropriate behavior both before and after a work Christmas function in 2014. There still appears to be a need to educate employees about behavior at work Christmas functions, as the wave of unfair dismissal cases resulting from work Christmas parties continues. In this blog post I will summarize the case of McDaid v Future Engineering and Communication Pty Ltd [2016] FWC 343.

Key principles

A work Christmas party is a work event, meaning the employer’s policies and codes of conduct will generally apply to employees at work Christmas parties. Behavior management and disciplinary processes for breach of a policy or code of conduct will be the same for behavior at a work Christmas party as for behavior during ordinary work hours.  Inappropriate behavior at a work Christmas party can be sufficient reason for dismissal, particularly where the behavior effects the safety and welfare of other employees.

Work Christmas parties ordinarily occur within a set time frame. Behavior that occurs after a work Christmas party has ended at an unofficial after party will not ordinarily be considered behavior that occurred in the course of employment. However, it is still possible for an employee to be dismissed from their employment for conduct that occurs outside the workplace.

McDaid v Future Engineering and Communication Pty Ltd [2016] FWC 343

Facts

Mr McDaid was employed by Future Engineering and Communication Pty Ltd (FEC) as a Project Coordinator. FEC held a staff Christmas event on 19 December 2014 which involved a day of go-karting followed by a Christmas party on FEC premises. FEC provided alcohol, soft drink and food, and did not provide any controls on the amount of alcohol consumed. The party was held in an area where there was a swimming pool. Although the conduct occurred on 19 December 2014 and Mr McDaid’s employment was terminated on 17 March 2015, and an application for unfair dismissal must be made within 21 days, a decision was not made until 2016 due to unsuccessful attempts at conciliation.

Mr McDaid had a history of behaving in an aggressive manner towards other employees in the workplace. He attended the go-karting event and then quickly became intoxicated at the Christmas party. He was aggressive towards Mr Sinna, a Design Engineer at FEC and pushed him several times in the chest. Mr Davies, FEC’s General Manager, intervened at one point and told Mr McDaid he should go home. After a short period, Mr McDaid continued to harangue Mr Sinna, became physically aggressive towards Mr Sinna and threw Mr Sinna into the swimming pool fully clothed.

Mr Davies approached Mr McDaid and told him to leave the premises. Mr McDaid then pushed Mr Davies twice, on the second occasion with such force that Mr Davies was propelled backward, hit the front gate of the premises and suffered some minor injuries. After Mr McDaid helped Mr Davies to his feet the two men started to exchange blows until Mr Davies hit Mr McDaid on the side of the head.

Mr McDaid’s employment with FEC was terminated on 17 March 2016 for reason of his behavior at the FEC work Christmas party. Mr McDaid filed an application for unfair dismissal with the Fair Work Commission. Conciliation failed and the matter was heard by Commissioner Williams.

Legal analysis

A national system employee to which the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act) applies is protected from unfair dismissal if they have served the minimum employment period (6 months or 12 months for small business employers), and if they earn less than the high income threshold (currently $138,900 per year) (see s.382 Fair Work Act). Mr McDaid satisfied this criteria. Section 385 provides that an unfair dismissal will have occurred where:

(a)  the person has been dismissed; and
(b)  the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and
(c)  the dismissal was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code; and
(d)  the dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy.

In Mr McDaid’s case, the issue to be determined was whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. Section 387 provides eight criteria the FWC must take into account when determining whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable:

1 Whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the person's capacity or conduct (including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees)

The three incidents that occurred during the Christmas party were each alone valid reason to dismiss Mr McDaid. Haranguing Mr Sinna, verbally abusing him, pushing him and throwing him in the pool was a valid reason for dismissal. Refusing to leave the property when directed to do so by the General Manager was a valid reason for dismissal. Initiating a fight with Mr Davies, and pushing him into the gate with such force he sustained minor injuries was a valid reason for dismissal.

2. Whether the person was notified of that reason

Mr McDaid was notified FEC was investigating his conduct at the Christmas party. Over a number of meetings between FEC and Mr McDaid in January 2016 and March 2016 it was made clear to Mr McDaid his behavior at the Christmas party was being investigated. After Mr McDaid was terminated on 17 March 2016 he was notified in writing of the reason for his dismissal.

3. Whether the person was given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to the capacity or conduct of the person

Mr McDaid was given numerous opportunities to respond. On the morning meeting held on 17 March 2016 he was given full opportunity to explain himself. At this meeting Mr McDaid read his version of events from a written statement he had prepared. FEC told Mr McDaid his version conflicted with other accounts and that they would respond later that day. Mr McDaid’s employment was terminated later that day on 17 March 2016.

4. Any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal

Mr McDaid had his support person Mr Horner, a Field Manager at FEC, present at discussions including those held on 17 March 2016, the date of dismissal.

5.  If the dismissal related to unsatisfactory performance by the person--whether the person had been warned about that unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal

The reason for dismissal was conduct at the Christmas party, not unsatisfactory work performance.

6. The degree to which the size of the employer's enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal and

7. The degree to which the absence of dedicated human resource management specialists or expertise in the enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal

FEC designs, manufactures, and installs communication towers, powerline infrastructure and associated equipment throughout Australia and has about 60 employees. As a medium sized business with no dedicated human resource employees the procedures followed were appropriate.

8. Any other matters that the FWC considers relevant.

The FWC noted Mr McDaid’s history of aggressive behavior towards colleagues in the workplace and that the behavior at the work Christmas party was not an isolated incident. The FWC also noted Mr Davies’ behavior on the night, especially given his role as General Manager. However, the FWC concluded the fight between Mr McDaid and Mr Davies was instigated by Mr McDaid and Mr Davies was therefore acting in self-defence.

Commissioner Williams dismissed the application and held that Mr McDaid was not unfairly dismissed and that this outcome was not surprising given his behavior.

Conclusions

Mr McDaid’s case was fairly clear cut. An employee cannot harass a colleague, throw a colleague into a pool, and start a physical altercation with the General Manager causing injury without expecting consequences. While not all cases are as clear cut, employees should be aware of the kind of conduct at a work Christmas party that may form a reason for dismissal. Instigating fights with colleagues, harassing colleagues, and even failing to leave the premises when directed may constitute valid reasons for dismissal. Employees are reminded that the standard of behavior ordinarily expected in their workplace will be the standard of behavior expected at the work Christmas party.

The consumption of alcohol is not an excuse for poor behavior, even where the alcohol is provided or paid for by the employer. In certain situations an employer may be held responsible for the provision of alcohol such as where a drunk employee falls down stairs. However, alcohol consumption is not accepted as an excuse for bad behavior and certainly not physically violent behavior.

Employers should be aware that the appropriate procedures to follow in conducting an investigation and making a decision to terminate an employee’s conduct will vary depending on factors such as the employer’s size and whether the employer has any human resource capacity. Mr McDaid attended a number of meetings with a support person and was provided with a number of opportunities to respond before the decision to terminate was made.

Please be careful at your work functions this Christmas season and hopefully I won’t have to write another blog post on the same topic next year!




Tuesday, 21 June 2016

Timesheet fraud – is lying about time worked on your timesheet ever ok?

Question: Is lying about time worked on your timesheet ever ok?
Answer: I want to scream at you NO. NO. NO. It is never ok to put incorrect times on your timesheet. Not only is this dishonest (which should be deterrent enough), but there is always the risk your timesheet discrepancies will be sufficient reason to justify immediate termination of your employment. However, instead of lecturing you, I am going to provide examples from case law to highlight how important accurate timesheets are to keeping your job.



The most recent unfair dismissal case on falsified timesheets
Lacase v Neon Group Ltd Ltd [2016] FWC 3058
Mr Lacase worked for Neon Cosmetics, an Australian cosmetics manufacturer, as a Compounding Supervisor. Mr Lacase was dobbed in by a fellow employee who Mr Lacase had told about claiming overtime without actually working the overtime hours. Mr Lacase’s ordinary hours were 7:45am to 3:51am. Mr Lacase had been claiming morning overtime payments of about 1 to 1.5 hours a day, which would put his start time to 6:45 or 6:15am so that in a normal week Mr Lacase would claim 38 normal hours and 6 overtime hours in his time sheets. The company’s Production Planner checked to see whether Mr Lacase was at work at these times by observing whether Mr Lacase’s car was in the staff carpark. It was not. When the allegations were put to Mr Lacase he denied he was lying about time worked on time sheets and that he was not working the overtime he was claiming. His employment was then terminated. Mr Lacase made an unfair dismissal application to the Fair Work Commission within the 21 day limitation period.

Commissioner Wilson decided that the termination was justified and Mr Lacase had not been unfairly dismissed:
·         In deciding on the balance of probabilities whether the alleged misconduct (fabricated timesheets) actually occurred the Commission will take into account whether it is satisfied of the proofs of the conduct and the need for honesty on the part of the applicant during the course of an investigation. Commissioner Wilson found that Mr Lacase had both claimed overtime on timesheets that had not been worked and had not been truthful when allegations were put to him. This is reason for dismissal.
·         Mr Lacase claimed that he worked overtime on various days and then aggregated his claims for overtime payment into a single period. Commissioner Wilson commented that this may be a potential defence where corroborative evidence of the matter is put forward, but Mr Lacase did not put such evidence forward in this situation.



Claiming time where you were actually working on your own business is sufficient reason for summary dismissal
Eghlima and another v Winco Systems Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 10836
Two brothers, David and Hamid, were employed as electricians by Winco Systems. They had worked on a number of projects including at the University of Sydney and the Star City Casino prior to being dismissed. David and Hamid had started their own electricians business without notifying Winco and had been conducting work in direct competition with Winco Systems in the time they had recorded as working for Winco. There were issues with the timesheets David and Hamid had completed in time claimed when the timesheets were compared to objective evidence such as phone, site and toll records and the discrepancies can be explained by time spent working on their own business. Deputy President Sams found the discrepancies “alarming and most disconcerting”. The discrepancies were very large for some projects, with 33 days being claimed for one particular project, but site access records showing David only worked 12 days and Hamid only worked 6 days. Given the evidence, Deputy President Sams found that even if the brothers resignation could be characterised as a dismissal, it would not have been unfair.



What if I am only claiming a little bit extra on my timesheet?
No. No. No. Even small amounts of additional time claimed on a timesheet may form a sufficient reason for dismissal, especially when combined with other conduct, such as if the employee acts deceptively towards an employer when the discrepancy is put to them.

One hour of overtime claimed on timesheet not actually worked – sufficient reason for dismissal
Ferris v Water-It Queensland Pty Ltd T/A Dig It Landscapes Pty Ltd [2013] FWC 7158
Mr Ferris was employed as a leading hand landscape gardener by Water-It. Water-It alleged that Mr Ferris had incorrectly completed his timesheet entry for 13 March 2013, adding an hour of overtime in which he had not worked. The previous day, Mr Ferris has received a reminder that timesheets were to be completed accurately and no overtime was to be performed without prior approval on that particular project and that failure to accurately complete start and finish times could lead to disciplinary action. The timesheet said Mr Ferris finished work at 5:30, but GPS evidence showed he finished work at 4:18 and arrived home at 4:55pm. Mr Ferris did not justify his conduct or seek an opportunity to review the timesheet, diary or other documents in this meeting where the discrepancy was put to him. In the course of the hearing Mr Ferris indicated that he claimed the additional hour in lieu of a call out he attended to later that evening. However, this overtime claim had not received the required prior approval.
 In considering whether there was a valid reason for dismissal relating to Mr Ferris’ conduct, Senior Deputy President Richards noted:

·         Mr Ferris had filled in his timesheet incorrectly despite the previous day being reminded of the importance of accurately completing timesheets and being provided with examples of how to correctly fill out a timesheet;
·         Although Mr Ferris claimed the hour was for a call out he attended later that day, he did not disclose this to his employer when given the opportunity – Mr Ferris did not avail himself of the opportunity to explain his defence. Regardless, the overtime claim had not received prior approval;
·         The 1 hour discrepancy alone was sufficient reason for dismissal when combined with the deceptive manner in which Mr Ferris acted when confronted with the discrepancy and seeking to mislead his employer about the time he arrived home, as the issue of trust and confidence arose when the matter was not openly and honestly explained by Mr Ferris when the employer was making inquiries.
 

Monday, 29 February 2016

Budden v Finke Enterprises Pty Ltd [2016] FWC 562 – employer can direct you to change your hair colour and a retaliatory response could constitute reason for dismissal

Thinking of dying your hair a crazy colour for charitable purposes? You might want to think again, as an employer may be able to lawfully direct you to change your hair colour and a failure to comply with a lawful direction may constitute reason for dismissal. You should also think twice about the way you react to a warning about your hair colour or appearance, as your reaction alone may be a sufficient reason for dismissal. In the recent case of Budden v Finke Enterprises Pty Ltd [2016] FWC 562, the employee’s reaction to a direction to change hair colour was a valid reason for dismissal under s.387(a) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

Unfair dismissal – the basics
To come within the unfair dismissals jurisdiction of the Fair Work Commission, an applicant must first meet a number of qualifying criteria, including the minimum employment period of 6 months or 12 months for small business employers (s.383), and come within the limitation period of 21 days (s.394). An unfair dismissal will only have occurred where the criteria in s.385 are satisfied:
(a)    The person has been dismissed; and
(b)   The dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and
(c)    The dismissal was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (where applicable); and
(d)   The dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy.

In Ms Budden’s case, the focus was on s.385(b), whether the dismissal was “harsh, unjust or reasonable”. In considering whether a dismissal is “harsh, unjust or unreasonable”, the criteria in s.387 must be taken into account:

(a)  whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the person's capacity or conduct (including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees); and
(b)  whether the person was notified of that reason; and
(c)  whether the person was given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to the capacity or conduct of the person; and
(d)  any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal; and
(e)  if the dismissal related to unsatisfactory performance by the person--whether the person had been warned about that unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal; and
(f)  the degree to which the size of the employer's enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
(g)  the degree to which the absence of dedicated human resource management specialists or expertise in the enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
(h)  any other matters that the FWC considers relevant.

While all the criteria in s.387 must be taken into account, the focus in Ms Budden’s case was on s.387(a), whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the person’s capacity or conduct.

Facts
Ms Budden was employed part time by Finke Enterprises to work five hours a day Monday to Friday at Fused Café. Ms Budden was the most senior cook employed. She was passionate about raising awareness about breast cancer and persuaded the Directors of Finke Enterprises to raise funds for breast cancer research in October 2015. The Directors agreed to donate 10c from every hot beverage sold as well as part proceeds from the sale of pink slices cooked by Ms Budden. There were two separate issues that led to Ms Budden being issued with a formal warning on 17 September 2015 and later put forward as a valid reason for dismissal under s.387(a) of the Fair Work Act 2009:
1.       Making derogatory comments about her employer to colleagues after she dyed her hair fluorescent pink and was directed to dye it a more work appropriate colour; and
2.       Complaints from staff about intimidation and bullying.

Dyeing hair fluorescent pink
Without consulting with her employer, Ms Budden dyed her hair fluorescent pink on 10 September 2015 in preparation for the October breast cancer fundraising campaign. On 17 September 2015 Ms Budden was given a formal verbal warning giving her until the 21 September to change her hair colour. This was followed up by a phone call during which Ms Budden yelled and swore at a Director. A formal written warning was also issued reiterating the options for changing her hair colour, indicating her behaviour on the telephone was inappropriate and that any further issues would result in a review of her employment status.

Commissioner Saunders held that the direction to change hair colour was a lawful direction because:
1.       Customers of the cafĂ© could see Ms Budden in the kitchen and Ms Budden sometimes interacted with customers;
2.       The owner of a cafĂ© is entitled to require staff working in a cafĂ© to have a neat and professional appearance;
3.       The owner offered a number of reasonable options including for Ms Budden to dye her hair a lighter “ash pink” colour for the duration of the breast cancer fundraising month;  and
4.       The fact the employer had previously accepted Ms Budden’s different hair colours did not matter, as those hair colours were not fluorescent.

While Ms Budden reluctantly followed the direction and dyed her hair a more subtle cranberry colour, she was not happy and vented to her colleagues. In particular, at an employee’s 21st birthday in which many of her colleagues were present, Ms Budden approached a number of colleagues and indicated she was angry she had to change her hair colour and made statements such as “would you like me to show you what it looked like before they fucking made me change it?”.

A final meeting was held on 21 September 2015 with management to give Ms Budden an opportunity to apologise or provide a comment on her behaviour. Ms Budden stormed out a number of times, returning only to make angry comments and storm off again. The decision was then made to dismiss Ms Budden. 

While Commissioner Saunders relied more on the intimidation grounds for dismissal discussed below, he also found Ms Budden’s behaviour in bad-mouthing her employer to be a valid reason for dismissal as her behaviour viewed objectively was likely to cause serious damage to the relationship of trust and confidence with her employer. As Ms Budden had complied with the direction to change her hair colour, Commissioner Saunders did not have to consider whether a failure to comply with the direction would have been a valid reason for dismissal. It is likely it would have been a valid reason for dismissal given if the direction was lawful, as the refusal would likely effect the trust and confidence between parties in the employment relationship.

Staff complaints of intimidation and bullying
Prior to the verbal and written warnings issued on 17 September 2015 Ms Budden had received a number of warnings about her intimidating behaviour including yelling aggressively at staff, putting staff down, calling staff names such as “idiot”, slapping a staff member’s hand, criticising staff members behind their back, and criticising the cafĂ©’s owners. There was also a particular incident where Ms Budden cornered a junior employee and asking if she was scared of her. The warnings on 17 September 2015 also included a further warning about her intimidating behaviour.

Commissioner Saunders found Ms Budden’s behaviour was a valid reason for dismissal, as an employer has obligations of health and safety to employees in the workplace and Ms Budden negatively impacted on the health and wellbeing of other employees. The fact Ms Budden’s “style” was direct and blunt and she did not personally see anything wrong with her behaviour did not prevent her intimidating behaviour being a valid reason for dismissal.

Conclusion
The case of Budden v Finke Enterprises is a good example of how things can rapidly spiral out of control for an employee who takes a direction from an employer too personally and does not think before they act to bad-mouth their employer. If you do plan to dye your hair a crazy colour, even for charity, ensure your employer is supportive of the change, as you will be required to comply with a lawful direction where an employer is entitled to require staff to have a neat and professional appearance. If you are directed to change your hair colour or appearance, the best course of action will usually be to make the change as directed and refrain from bad-mouthing your employer, especially to colleagues. This includes bad-mouthing your employer on social media, as tempting and satisfying as it may seem at the time. An apology or considered explanation for certain behaviour can go a long way to preventing dismissal if you do act in a way that diminishes your employer’s confidence in you.    


Monday, 30 November 2015

Personal use of work mobile phones – what are the limits? Applicant v NBN Co Limited [2015] FWC 7412

Do you have a work provided phone? Do you use this phone for personal phone calls? If your answers are yes and yes, this blog post is a must read. In Applicant v NBN Co Limited [2015] FWC 7412 (NBN Co Case) an NBN Co employee was dismissed after the employee accumulated $22,630 worth of personal international calls made to numbers in India and failed to co-operate effectively in paying this money back. The employee’s unfair dismissal application failed. Most work places permit “reasonable personal use” of work provided phones and mobile phones - however, policies differ, and you should check the relevant policies at your workplace which will usually indicate whether you can use your phone for personal use and the limits of that personal use.

A.      The NBN Co Case - Facts
An NBN Co employee used his work provided phone to make personal calls to his family in India, incurring international call costs of $22,630 in the period May to September 2004. Over a period of nine months, NBN Co attempted to come to an agreement with the employee about the repayment of the money, holding a number of meetings with the employee and his representative over this time. On 25 June 2015 after the employee continued to refuse to come to an agreement, NBN Co terminated his employment.

B.      Was the employee’s termination an unfair dismissal?
Section 385 of the Fair Work Act 2009 lists the criteria that must be established for an unfair dismissal:
(a)  the person has been dismissed; and
(b)  the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable; and
(c)  the dismissal was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code; and
(d)  the dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy.

In considering whether the dismissal was “harsh, unjust or unreasonable”, the FWC must take into account the criteria in s.387:
(a)  whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the person's capacity or conduct (including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees); and
(b)  whether the person was notified of that reason; and
                (c)  whether the person was given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to the capacity or conduct of the person; and
                (d)  any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal; and
                (e)  if the dismissal related to unsatisfactory performance by the person--whether the person had been warned about that unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal; and
                (f)  the degree to which the size of the employer's enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
                (g)  the degree to which the absence of dedicated human resource management specialists or expertise in the enterprise would be likely to impact on the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal; and
                (h)  any other matters that the FWC considers relevant.
 
NBN put forward two reasons which combined constituted a valid reason for dismissal:
1.       The employee’s excessive use of the phone in breach of policies; and
2.       The employee’s refusal to agree to a repayment plan.

Breach of policies
There were two relevant NBN Co policies:
1.       IT Equipment Policy
The IT Equipment Policy gave the employer the right to audit and review phone and data usage and if inappropriate use is identified the policy allows NBN to recover costs from the employee and commence disciplinary action including termination of employment. Accounts where the monthly call charge is greater than $75 are to be investigated under the policy. The employee was aware of this policy.

2.       Acceptable Use Guideline
The Guidelines permit reasonable personal use of mobile calling within Australia only.

The employee claimed he was not aware of the Acceptable Use Guideline at the relevant time, being the time he was making the personal international phone calls. While the employee was not provided with a copy of the Guideline at his induction:
·         there was nothing in the induction suggesting unlimited personal international calls was permitted; and
·         the IT Equipment Policy of which the employee was aware stated that use of work provided mobile phones will be monitored and if monthly call costs exceed $75, they will be investigated.

In these circumstances the employee should have taken steps to find out whether he could make personal international calls on the work provided phone and locate the relevant policy. The employee did not ask his manager about call costs or seek out the Guideline.

Deputy President Gooley also noted that NBN Co did not follow their own policies in monitoring phone usage. NBN Co did not review usage for all accounts where usage exceeded $75 as required by the IT Equipment Policy. The employee’s call usage was on average $8,000 - $12,000 per month, far beyond the $75 investigation threshold, yet it took months for the employer to review the account. Even when the issue was identified, the employee was not initially told the full extent of the money he owed. The employee was notified of about $7,500 worth of personal calls in September 2014, but it was not until later that a full investigation found $22,630 was owed and the employee was notified of this revised amount. Had the employee been aware of the matter sooner, he would have stopped making the personal international calls.

Refusal to agree to a repayment plan
Where a debt is owed to an employer and there is a legitimate basis for the debt to be disputed, the mere existence of the debt alone will not be a valid reason for dismissal. However, in this case, Deputy President Gooley held that there was no reasonable basis for the employee to dispute the debt, as the policies were incorporated into his employment contract and he had clearly breached the policies. It was unreasonable for him to refuse to enter into an agreement plan to repay the money, and this was a valid reason for dismissal.

The key to Deputy President Gooley’s decision was that NBN Co had managed the investigative procedure in accordance with procedural fairness, giving the employee several opportunities to come to an agreement for repayment.

NBN Co organised a number of meetings over a period of nine months to try and come to an agreement on a repayment plan. Over this time, the employee changed his stance several times, initially offering to repay the amount, repaying $7,500 and asking not to be required to repay the remainder, and finally retracting his offer to repay the amount. NBN Co sent a warning letter in February 2015 stating that the employee had breached NBN Co policies and that if the outstanding amount of $15,130 was not repaid, NBN Co would consider further disciplinary action including the likely termination of employment. On 11 June 2015, after a number of unsuccessful meetings between the employer and employee, NBN Co issued a show cause letter asking the employee to accept a proposed repayment plan of $200 per fortnight or for the employee to propose an alternative regular repayment, or NBN Co would consider further disciplinary action including termination of employment. A number of further meetings were held. On 25 June 2015 the employee and the employee’s representative attended a meeting where various proposals were discussed, by the employee would not move on his non-negotiable position that the final warning be revoked, and NBN Co terminated the employee’s employment. Section 387 directs attention to whether the applicant was given an opportunity to respond and was notified of reasons for dismissal. All of the steps NBN Co took in providing sufficient opportunities to come to an agreement were important in the refusal to come to a repayment plan being a valid reason for dismissal.

C.      Key points from the NBN Co Case
Employees
1.       You may have to take your own steps to access IT policies relevant to phone usage. Do not assume that you can use a work provided phone for personal use.
2.       One policy may direct your attention to another policy – make sure you seek out the second policy. In the NBN Co Case the employee was aware of the first policy which indicated there were restrictions on personal use of work provided mobile phones. The employee was aware of this first policy and should have sought out the second policy which described in more detail the boundaries of the personal use.
3.       If you are unsure about whether you can use your work phone for personal use or the extent to which you are permitted to use your phone for personal use, make sure you clarify your concerns with your manager prior to using your phone for personal use. In the NBN Co Case Deputy President Gooley stated “the Applicant should have made inquiries of his managers. Without express advice that a work provided phone can be used for both personal and local use and internal calls an employee cannot simply assume that such use is approved”.

Employers
1.       When providing mobile phones to employees, the employer should point out the relevant policies that apply and provide employees with access to these policies.
2.       It is important to ensure investigation and usage management practices in policies are complied with. In the NBN Co Case the IT Equipment Policy stated that phone usage will be investigated where call costs exceeded $75 per month. These investigations were not always conducted when the $75 trigger point was met.
3.       Successfully managing an employee who has potentially breached a policy by using their work provided phone for prohibited personal use may take months. An employee must be given an opportunity to respond to allegations and have a support person present at discussions relating to the dismissal. If there are reasonable alternatives to termination, these should be considered. 
4.       Ordinarily the fact an employee has a debt to the employer alone will not be sufficient to justify dismissal, especially where the employee has reasonable grounds to challenge the employee’s finding. Alternatives to dismissal may be available in these situations.
5.       Where an employee makes a formal grievance complaint about the investigative process, ensure the grievance complaint is considered and responded to prior to further action (such as termination of employment) is taken.